Sunday, August 17, 2014

MANAGING MICROFINANCE INSTITUTIONS IN DIFFICULT ECONOMIC TIMES



Difficult  economic conditions prevailing in a country can  pose a challenge to enterprise development, sustainability and growth processes. Many enterprises including microfinance institutions will have to face the realities and develop the needed approach in order to sustain their operations.

The effect of  economic challenges on micro and small enterprises (MSEs)  will include but not limited to increasing  need for additional working  capital to manage the same size of  businesses, reduction in production or sales volumes, high  production cost and cashflow challenges.

Microfinance institutions (MFIs) as financiers of microenterprises will face various challenges just like the enterprises they finance.  This is largely because what happens to their clients in most cases is mirrored in their operations. For instance the inability of the clients to increase or maintain volumes and values of their sales can directly affect the repayment of their loans. Low volumes of sales can also affect the volume of deposits that can be mobilized.

The challenge for MFIs and other financialinstitutions in difficult economic times will be evident in decline in deposits mobilization,low loan recovery rates,high operational or transaction cost as well as high cost associated with borrowings and difficulty in raising the needed loans to support operations.

The decrease in deposits and low recovery rates are due to the fact that clients or micro and small entrepreneurs in view of their need for additional capital will quickly plough back available money in order to ensure that their enterprises can operate and generate the returns needed to meet other demands which may include repayment of loans, savings and household consumption. By this, therefore, income received from sales is directly used to restock their enterprises for fear of price changes. In some cases where clients are able to save, they do that in reduced amounts and such amounts do not stay long with the MFIs.

Microfinance operations are naturally expensive. This is due to the very nature of the microfinance business which involves making small loans and taking small deposits. The cost of transacting one loan or taking a deposit is very expensive. Owners and operators of microfinance institutions must not be oblivious of the challenging economic situation. MFIs  must prepare and implement the needed operational or managerial strategy to ensure that their businesses are able to continue to provide the needed support to MSEs and still be financially and operationally sustainable.

WHAT SHOULD MFIs EXPECT
Expensive Operations:
 The cost of operating MFIs is likely to increase due to general increase in prices of goods and services. The cost to income ratio is an important measure of profitability for MFIs. With the current economic conditions MFIs will register high “additional” operating cost. The challenge here is that the interest income which is the main source of income for MFIs will not proportionally grow in line with the operational cost. The failure to control the operational cost can, therefore, lead to a high cost to income ratio and further affect the operational fortunes of  MFIs. MFIs will need to implement controls that will lead to cost reduction. They must pay closer attention to growing and maintaining quality loans in order to improve their interest income.

High cost of capital:
MFIs in Ghana incur a high cost in raising funds to support their operations. With rise in inflation and other factors, MFIs in Ghana will further be required to pay more for the loans they contract. The high cost of the loans is due to unstable economic situation which is perceived by investors whether local or foreign as a high risk. The high cost of capital is, therefore, to compensate for the risk associated with the entire macro-economic situation and also to protect the value of their investments placed with the MFIs.

Short terms loans for MFIs:
Aside the high cost of capital, MFIs will witness that most investors will be willing to offer short term investments instead of providing long term investments.Shorter term credits will prevail because most investors are skeptical of the future developments of the economy that can further affect the value of their funds. The dangers with shorter term credits for MFIs is that it may affect the cashflow position of the MFIs. The challenge with short term loans made to MFIs is that MFIs are unable to fully invest these funds in order to record the needed returns to compensate for the cost incurred in raising such funds. MFIs can address this by ensuring to invest such funds in activities that have similar repayment patterns compared with the borrowed facility.

Reduction in deposit mobilization:
MFIs will experience reduction in deposits mobilization. Deposits are one of the key sources of funding for MFIs. MFIs spend to mobilize in order to place the funds mobilized in loans and other investments. Under difficult economic situations, the enterprises of client are financially stretched and the income from these enterprises will dwindle. This is expected to negatively affect the savings habits of these clients. This, therefore, means that clients will not have enough income to spend and save. Clients will prioritize their consumption smoothing needs instead of savings or loan repayments. The other obvious thing is that because the general cost of items have gone up, microclients will have to use more of their little income to buy what they need. All these development have the tendency that will affect the loan repayment potentials of the clients in questions.

Conclusion
Acknowledging the current economic challenges as an owner of a MFI is one step to ensure that MFIs can be able to stay financially sound to support operations and be able to reach out to targeted clients.   The good thing with MFIs and difficult economic conditions is that, there is much evidence to support the fact that MFIs have the potential of surviving harsh economic conditions if prudent steps are implemented. This is made evident by the growth registered by the microfinance industry during the world economic crisis. 

Sustainability of the MFIs is an important step to ensure that MFIs will be available to support the economic empowerment of their clients through the provision of financial and non-financial services.
MFIs must ensure to prioritize the management of their liquidity. This will include having to constantly or frequently review the liquidity positions. This can be performed on weekly basis or at least on monthly basis. Instead of depending on only one person to make decision on the liquidity status of the MFIs, it is advisable to use small committees instead of one man reviews.

MFIs must reduce or suspend capital investments and rather fund more liquid assets. This is because MFIs would have challenges with raising funds and, therefore, must be able to internally make funds available for investments in areas that will yield better returns to support increase in operational cost. MFIs can hold on to branch expansion and rather seek to improve the efficiency of their operations.

MFIs must ensure to do proper and detailed loan analysis for all their loan requests. Credit officers or managers  should not only assess the “ability to pay”loans only based on the financial position of the clients  but must include assessing  the entrepreneurial competencies  of the clients to better make informed decisions to manage and grow their business enterprise. In addition, MFIs must ensure to diversify their loan portfolio by ensuring to finance clients involved in different economic activities instead of financing clients involved in just one economic activity.


This is the time MFIs must place priority on efficiency instead of expansion. MFIs should improve their liquidity management to meet the frequent cash withdrawal and also aim at lean operations. MFIs must survive to support the micro and small entrepreneurs and this can be only achieved if owners and managers of MFIs make inform decisions regarding the day to day operations of their enterprises.

Wednesday, May 28, 2014

Microfinance is for the empowerment of the poor and the low income earners. They are not to serve the already served population.

WILL MY MICROFINANCE COMPANY COLLAPSE?



I encountered an “owner manager” of a microfinance company who had signed onto a one on one microfinance operational support and advice session. During the course of our discussions we spoke on the challenging facing the Ghanaian microfinance sector. I mentioned in our discussions that over 50 microfinance had collapsed as at end 2013. This particular subject led the owner manager to ask a question that I found quite revealing.
The “owner manager” made a confession and stated that “anytime I hear the news of microfinance companies collapsing I feel very uneasy and very much afraid. I always ask myself; will my microfinance company collapse”?  
In my dealing with microfinance companies I have not thought about personalizing the challenges within the sector although I have looked at the issues from the operational point of view. I am sure the fears of the owner manager was largely the point that the failure of the company would mean that he would have several liabilities to deal with. This is because the capital invested in that business was not entirely his own and that he was answerable to the depositors and other investors.
The “manager owner” was expecting an answer for his question. Something that I have not really thought off. Well I told him “the answer to your question is that your company will collapse if you do what caused the failure of those companies”.  This article will look at some of the things that might have contributed to the collapse of some of the MFIs. I am sure these pointers can provide answers to other owners of MFIs who are battling with the fear of whether their microfinance companies will collapse.
This article is not a scientist explanation of the causes of collapse of some microfinance companies but from an operational point of view to explain why your microfinance company will collapse if you do what will cause it to collapse.

 FACTORS THAT LEAD TO MICROFINANCE COLLAPSES
To start with it is important to note that business collapse can be fueled by two main factors: external or internal factors.   

External Factors
The external factors are largely the economic, political environment within which the business is operating. The external factors are economically related to the happening within a defined nation and sometimes even at the world level. A typical example is the effect of the world economic crisis which happened in 2008. This crisis affected business across certain parts of the world including Africa. The external factors may also include, high inflation rate, foreign exchange rates, regulatory policies, political decisions, economic opportunities or markets, etc. For instance, the absence of adequate economic opportunities in a particular country or region cannot guarantee the efficient loan repayments. Lack of economics opportunities will prevent loan clients within such catchment areas from finding the needed opportunity to invest the loans they secure so as to repay the loans they contract from the MFIs or banks. High occurrence of such events can therefore lead to high poor loan performance and therefore can affect the overall sustainability of the MFI.
With reference to the collapses of MFIs in Ghana, the role of external factors like the risk arising from regulatory or compliance, market and foreign exchange contributing to the collapsing MFIs cannot be compared with factors arising from the competencies of the owners, board and staff of the collapsed microfinance institutions or what can best be referred to as internal factors.
Internal Factors
Internal factors that can negatively affect the operations of the MFIs are the day to day decisions and actions of the staff and management of the MFIs. These activities have a measure of risk which when not managed adequately can affect the entire operations of the MFIs.
Risk is very central to the management of MFIs just like any other financial institution. Financial institutions including MFIs are responsible for the distribution of financial resources within any economy. They mobilize financial resources from the “haves” in the society as deposits and make them available to the “have nots” as loans or credits. These activities involve the management of risk.  The MFIs are to ensure that the money they mobilize from the “haves” can come back to them with some added value in the terms of interest. On the side of the “have nots” they are to ensure that loans or credit extended to these people can be repaid. These two events are all risk centered activities which should be managed to ensure that neither the depositor nor the borrower become a negative risk to the activities of the MFIs.the
Microfinance institutions are more prone to risk. This is because they deal with the part of the population that have been known to be highly risky. These clients are risky because they have low level of education, are involved in enterprises that are risky, live in areas that are known to have poor sanitation and therefore high incidence of diseases, have no or little access to health care facilities, do not have reliable income, etc.
Another pointer of risk is the fact that microfinance is a business of small volumes. This therefore means that there are several small element of risk associated with the various small transactions. Each small transaction comes with cost. This is one reason that explains the high operational cost associated with microfinance. MFIs are, therefore, presented with the challenge to manage both inherent risk and cost in each of the small  transactions so as to stay in business.
The situation with most MFIs in Ghana is that although it is known that microfinance has high operational cost, most MFIs rather pursue activities that increases cost instead of keeping cost under control. For instance some MFI have adopted physical branch establishment in order to expand outreach and increase their share of the market. This system has led to a situation where such capital investments now competes with available funds for on-lending purposes. It is important to note that the loans and advances are the main source of income for microfinance. Growing bad loan or not having the needed funds to grow quality loans therefore means that a microfinance company may not be generating enough income to support its operations.
Most MFI in Ghana are keen about how their companies image. This has led to investment in image enhancement through office set up, branded office buildings, cars, etc. The problem here is not the image investment but the source of financing the image enhancement. Some MFIs have funded this using depositors funds. The owners expect that the branded image will lead to client confidence and further translate into increase business activities from their clients or investors. The inability to match the terms of these investments to the terms of clients deposits have led to liquidity mismatches.  The effects of poor liquidity management adopted by some MFI companies is one main thing that have threaten the existence of the microfinance companies. 

Managing MFIs for success
As indicated earlier microfinance is already an expensive business. Therefore for microfinance to achieve the objective of being sustainable through increasing outreach and achieving impact there are two ways to go about it. One way is to increase the volumes of transactions so as to be able to finance the cost of the MFIs. The second scenario is that as much as possible MFIs must try to cut down on any activity that have cost implication through being efficient. For instance MFIs must look at their staff needs very well before they undertake to hire more staff. Getting job executed within the MFIs is not necessary about having many staff. It is about improving the capacities of the staff to enable them to handle task effectively.
 The situation with the Ghanaian microfinance is that most owners actually take on staff who rather become a source of cost. To some owners, hiring or keeping a number of staff is more to satisfy “business ego” rather than for economic or business sense.  MFIs that intends to stay for long need to insist on ensuring that they have the acceptable staff to client load that can guarantee efficiency. The simple way to manage this is to ensure that the frontline staff or credit staff have the number of loans or deposit clients whose business with the MFI can pay for the cost of hiring that particular staff.
The other source of cost that have threaten the operations of the microfinance companies is the cost at which majority of them mobilize or take on investments. The other side to the cost is the terms or tenor for the borrowings (investments) or deposits. The cost of the investment made by investors to the MFIs ranges from 5 % to 10% per month. The high cost of investment has been necessitated by the lack of adequate source of competitive funds.  MFIs are, therefore, forced to take on these high cost investments which in most cases cannot be passed on as loans to generate the needed income to repay the investors on due dates.
The other challenge with regards to the cost of investments is the issue of the tenor. It can be observed that the sources of funds for the MFIs are mostly short term. The short term nature of the funds cannot allow them to adequately invest the funds for long term purposes. The interesting thing is that some MFIs can take on investment with only one month tenor and give loans for three months. Under this circumstances most MFIs are not able to effectively utilized the funds they contract and this rather become a cost to the MFIs that is if they are able to make payment when such investments are due.
The chances of a microfinance company failing is a factor of what is being done from within by the management and staff of  the microfinance and not what is happening outside it. These include how the financial resources are being managed, the attitude and lifestyles of the owners, their personal life styles and their business management skills. The microfinance companies that have become very successful are not only owned and managed by entrepreneurs. They are managed by people who have improved their understanding and skills in microfinance. This is what owners of microfinance companies in Ghana must aim at.
To prevent more microfinance companies from collapsing, there must be sustained investment in the board, management and staff of these companies. Owners, managers and other stakeholder must put much emphasis on how to improve knowledge and skills with regards to microfinance management. MFIs must analyze their outreach objectives, capital investment   and staff recruitment and ensure that all these actions do not become a drain on the resources of the company.  MFIs must focus on the microfinance business and avoid creating other investments or business entities using short term funds from the MFIs.  So to conclude a microfinance company will collapse if you fail to know that your success as a microfinance is not how much you spend but how much you generate from what you spend.

Monday, February 3, 2014

6 Resolutions for Microfinance Institutions in Ghana


The microfinance industry in Ghana during year 2013 witnessed some interesting developments. The year saw most microfinance institutions (MFIS) trying to position by building systems as required by the regulator.  During the same year, about 30 MFIs also went down raising fears amongst many stakeholders. This generated mixed perception about the business of microfinance in Ghana and many more questioned were asked whether microfinance was really a developmental tool. These questions were supported by the news of collapsing companies and the high interest rates charged by the MFIs.
During the year, the sector witnessed an increase in the capital requirement for establishing MFIs. The capital requirement of GHC100,000.00 for deposit taken institutions  was increased to GHC500,000.00 whiles that of non-deposit taken MFIs  increased from GHC60,000.00 to GHC250,000.00.  The overall objective of the increment was to increase the risk base of these MFIs and also raise the entry bar for establishing new MFIs.
Microfinance has been used to provide poor clients with the needed opportunity to take advantage of   economic and social opportunities in various developing countries like Bolivia, Bangladesh and Uganda.   It has served as a transformational tool contributing to the financial and non-financial capacities of the poor and the low income earners.    
 A look at the developing stages of miocrofinance markets reveals that the Ghanaian microfinance sector can best be said to be in second stage of microfinance development. This stage is characterized by the establishment of more MFIs and increasing clientele base but with only few product options.  The dominant products distributed by the MFIs are mainly microcredit and saving products. 
The third stage of microfinance development is when there are diverse products with accompanying increasing outreach. This stage is when clients can have the option of choosing among other products to meet their financial needs. This stage  should provides  products for insurance, housing, agric loans, warehouse finance, and other non financial services to the microfinance client without any  difficulty .
The Ghanaian microfinance    sector by far is yet to expand in terms of increasing outreach in to provide financial access to close to 50% of the people outside the formal financial sector.    The growth accompanying effective microfinance implementation can only be achieved through providing better understanding of microfinance as a developmental tool.
This article will share 6 key resolutions that microfinance institutions can make in the year 2014 in order to improve on their operations.
Increase Efficiency
Microfinance has high operational cost. Granting small loans and taking small deposits have high transactional cost. Microfinance is, therefore, a business of volumes. Increasing the number of transaction can help cover cost in order to be profitable. Another cost related element is non financial services which includes building the capacity of the clients. These are mostly done for microfinance clients but they do not directly yield any cash return to the MFIs.
Although Microfinance is very expensive business to undertake, it however, does not mean that nothing can be done to control the high cost associated with its operations. High operational cost is one reason that has been used to explain the high cost of microfinance loans. This can be as a result of inefficient operational systems adopted. For instance, cost can be increased or reduced when staff of MFIs are assigned to a number of loan clients (Client per credit officer) that are below or above the capacity of the officer.  
The level of skills or the skills sets of loan officers or deposit Officer can increase or decrease the cost of transactions to clients. For instance, loan officer’s ability to handle clients request on time can reduce the cost associated with a particular transaction. Some loan officers are not schooled on what to ask for when they interact with loan clients. Sometimes a single loan request becomes too expensive when the clients or officer would have to visit each other for additional information which can be avoided if there is a clear checklist available.
Additionally, using effective and reliable information technology systems can also help reduce the cost of transaction by reducing the time needed to execute all transactions.
For MFIs to remain sustainable, MFIs would have to develop efficient operational systems which must include improving the skills and knowledge of the credit officers to enable them to adequately manage the workloads that have been assigned to them. Managers of MFIs must also ensure that the clients to credit officers are within the acceptable limits to ensure efficiency and positive returns on their loan investments.
Liquidity Management
Liquidity management has been one of the most important challenges that have confronted many MFIs  in Ghana. This is one major thing that has contributed to the collapse of some of these companies. The reason of fraud associated to MFIs collapses may not be as dominant as the reasons linked to the inability of MFIs to prudentially manage their liquidity.
 Liquidity management guarantees a comfortable position for the MFIs to have available cash to manage it day to day activities. For the MFIs, these activities may include, loan disbursements, cash withdrawals, honouring the payment of investments to investors, etc.
To be sustainable, MFIs like most financial institutions are required to manage their cashflow efficiently. This will require making decision regarding what amount of cash that should be put into investments and which kind of investments (short, loan term or call deposit) is appropriate at a particular time to  invest in. How much should be made ready for daily, weekly withdrawals? How much cash will be mobilized as savings, etc?  These questions are very important in order for the MFIs to make the most out of the deposits that they mobilize.
The mistake some MFI managers commit   is how they the  depositors’ funds. Some are used for activities that may have longer maturity terms than that of the deposits. Some managers have used such funds to invest in office set ups and even purchased official vehicles thereby locking their cash in long term fixed assets.
To find ways around this, MFIs should consider borrowing from other financial institutions to finance some of their capital investments but should desist or reduce their desire for using deposits to undertake branch expansions, office facelifts, purchasing vehicles, etc.
 To stay in business in 2014 and beyond, MFIs will need to match the characteristics of their deposits to the investments they undertake. MFIs must also watch what they pay as interest to their investors and also negotiate terms on the investments so that at least they are pegged longer than their short term loans.
Capacity Building
The core of MFI business depends on the knowledge and skills of the credit officers or the officers that are constantly in contact with the clients. The frontline staff of  MFIs  are the key development actors in microfinance. They are required to understand their role as microfinance officers beyond the duty of granting loans and making recoveries. They must be educated to appreciate the dynamics behind how small loans can be used to improve the livelihoods of their clients. The truth is that many more officers within the microfinance industry cannot even comprehend the logic behind how small amounts of loans can assist in poverty reduction. They are microfinance workers in title but not in knowledge.
MFIs must try to increase the efficiencies of their workforce so as to increase impact and ensure sustainability. These can be achieved by  exposing microfinance  staff to various aspects of microfinance either through classroom training, workshop participation, industry exchange programmes and hands-on or on-the- spot training of staff. Training must be part of the main activities of MFIs and these must include training the board and management to appreciate the very nature and dynamics of transformational microfinance.
Get Board Active
The governing boards of microfinance institutions are important part for building vibrant microfinance institutions. Like any other board, they are required to formulate policies and supervise the implementation of the policies. The regulatory requirement mandates the formation of a board as part of the process of regulation.
The observation with most board of MFIs are that majority of them are not very active. On paper the boards exist but in reality majority of the boards do not have active proceedings to guide the whole governance process of the MFIs.  Some of the reasons necessitating the inactiveness of the board is the way and manner most of the board are formed. Most MFI owners choose board members they feel comfortable with but who may lack the needed skills and knowledge to help with managing the MFI.
In cases where some of the boards are active, the owners of the MFIs are sometimes more powerful than the board such that the board’s recommendations are subjected to the decision of the owner CEO.
An active and vibrant board is not about the names on your board. It is about the quality of people who can make time to meet, discuss and understand the business of microfinance and the associated challenges as well as the opportunities that can be take advantage of.
In 2014, MFIs must find ways of making their boards active not only in terms of meetings but to improve their role to provide policy guidance to help avoid the various pitfalls that most MFIs may find themselves.
Increase Outreach versus Sustainability
The aim of every MFI is to be able to reach out to many more people with their services and products. This has inspired MFIs to branch out to places that may be far away from their head offices. The MFIs either physically establish structures in these places or provide mobile services (susu) or banking on foots. Any of the branching method adopted to provide services to client have their own cost implications. The cost of managing branching if it is not compensated with the needed income can affect the overall financial and operational sustainability of the MFIs.  
When MFIs think of outreach, it is important to think of the cost and the returns. This will ensure that the systems including the human resource are not overly stretched. Some MFI have encountered operational problems with the onsite of increasing outreach. Outreach or branching can lead to inter-branch or agency mismatches which have been used mostly to undertake fraudulent deals by some staff due to weak internal systems.
In some other cases, the cost involved in financing the outreached is far beyond the income from such decision and this give rise to liquidity challenges. For instance,  some MFIs send officers to areas that are quite far from their operational center in order to provide services to clients in such communities. The number of clients and volumes of transaction in such communities may not be economically viable. The long term effect of such decision is that the MFI may commit resources from other quarters to maintain such activities which may affect the overall financial performance of the MFI. This is not to say MFIs should not increase outreach. What is recommended is that MFIs would have to increase efficiency with every decision to increase outreach in order to stay in business.
 Client Entrepreneurial Development  
The current trend shows that most MFIs in Ghana are not very focused on providing the needed capacity in the form of non-financial services to the clients. The MFIs are quick in providing loans to clients without first ensuring that the clients have the needed capacity to effectively manage their enterprises. The provision of the non-financial services can also assist the client in putting the loans to effective use. One of the striking differences between microfinance and other financial is the attention giving to clients which focuses on making them capable of managing their enterprises and household duties.  
To improve the impact of the microfinance sector in contributing to economic and social growth of their clients, MFIs must take a keen interest in micro enterprise development in order to provide the necessary support to their clients so as to help grow the enterprises of their clients.
Conclusion
The microfinance sector has the objective of meeting the financial demand of the poor and the low income earners. In the era of commercial microfinance, it is important for MFIs to increase their operational performance in order to be financially viable so as to continue in business. Improving the skills set of microfinance workers, proper management systems and quality governance are key contributors of efficiency. It is important for stakeholders to keep asking the one important question that is “what significant difference is microfinance making towards poverty reduction in Ghana”? There is the need for all stakeholders especially the MFIs to innovate and work towards making microfinance a developmental tool.